India's Adani hammered by NGT
Published by MAC on 2019-03-22Source: The News Minute
Not for the first time
By all rights (surely) Indian behemoth Adani is well overdue for enforced retirement - and that's putting it mildly.
In yet another blow, the country's National Green Tribunal has hit the firm with a large fine for multiple violations against people and the environment at a power plant in Karnataka.
But, true to its shappy form, Adani is set to appeal the order before the Indian Supreme Court.
India's National Green Tribunal fines Adani over US$ 72 milllion for Updupi Power plant; cancels extension plams
Adani is, however, expected to challenge the order in the Supreme Court.
Soumya Chatterjee
The News Minute
17 March 1 2019
In a big win for residents of Yellur village and other surrounding areas in Karnataka’s Udupi district, the National Green Tribunal (NGT) cancelled the environmental clearance given to industry behemoth Adani to expand its power plant in the area. Moreover, taking cognisance of the findings of an expert committee appointed by the NGT itself, Adani was fined Rs 5 crore as per the ‘polluters pay’ principle under Section 20 of the National Green Tribunal Act, 2010.
The residents of the area have been complaining for years about the ill-effects on public health and decreasing agricultural yield due to the Udupi Power Corporation Ltd.
The company has to pay the fine amount to the Central Pollution Control Board as an “interim environmental compensation” within one month. Moreover, Rs 1 lakh has to be paid by Adani to the petitioner in the case, Balakrishna Shetty, the executive president of Janajagruthi Samithi.
The same order noted that the extension of the environmental clearance granted in April 2002 of the current plant itself was illegal and done under ‘questionable circumstances at the request of the project proponent’.
The court further ordered that a committee comprising a senior scientist of the Central Pollution Control Board, a senior representative of IIT Chennai and a senior scientist at IIT Bangalore will assess the damage on account of the environmental violations in the areas of fly ash management, ash pond, ambient air quality, fugitive emissions, etc., which have undoubtedly caused severe damage to the environment and ecology of the area and submit its report within three months.
Noted human rights activist Vidya Dinker, who is associated with the case, said, “People have been speaking against the plant for a long time but when the Adanis took over, it was like all ways were blocked for them. Their only hope was the court. The NGT judgement now gives us vindication and there is hope that the proposed expansion won’t go through even though the Adanis will appeal in the Supreme Court. At the same time, there is a feeling that justice can prevail in this country.”
A 2012 report by a team of six scientists led by Professor TV Ramachandra said mismanagement of the environment was evident from the contamination of water (surface and ground), soil and air, apart from the impaired functional aspects of the biotic elements.
The report titled ‘Environmental Profile and People’s Livelihood aspects in the vicinity of Coal Based Thermal Power Plant’, said:
“This is evident from the reduced productivity (grains, jasmine flower, and horticultural produce – coconut, areca nut, and livestock – milk), reproductive ability (livestock, poultry animals).
Deposition of dust on the leaves is evident during the dry seasons. Also, deposition of dust with toxicants in the floral parts of the vegetation has induced phyto-toxicity leading to poor pollination and hence reduced productivity. Reduced population of pollinators (bees, etc.) has been reported in these villages due to the degradation of the environment.”