Glencore under Australian tax evasion probePublished by MAC on 2017-11-10
Source: Paradise Papers (2017-11-05)
The newly-released so-called Paradise Papers has prompted the Australian Tax Office to initiate action against 18 multinational companies.
One of these is Glencore, a major global mining company and the world's biggest metals trader.
The tax trick big miners use to avoid paying millions
ABC Four Corners and International Consortium of Investigative Journalists
5 November 2017
The Australian Tax Office (ATO) has taken action against 19 multinational
companies as it unpicks a scheme capable of pushing millions of tax
The ATO has taken action against 19 companies over a cross-currency
interest rate swap scheme
The ATO is seeking the Paradise Papers in order to analyse the
The Paradise Papers reveal mining giant Glencore used the currency
The ATO is also cracking down on high-profile Australian advisory firms
and an international web of offshore law firms suspected of promoting tax
avoidance schemes through tax havens.
The ATO investigations have come to light during a Four Corners project in
partnership with the International Consortium of Investigative
The largest leak of documents in history has exposed the tax secrets of a
host of large multinational companies.
The Paradise Papers leak has uncovered confidential emails, board minutes
and tax-structuring plans originating from global offshore law firm
Appleby, Singaporean firm Asiaciti Trust and 19 corporate registries in
tax havens, obtained by German newspaper Suddeutsche Zeitung.
The documents show how major multinationals have used the tax haven of
Bermuda to structure their Australian debts and employ complicated
financing schemes for their Australian subsidiaries, with the suspected
goal of dramatically cutting their Australian tax bill.
The cache of leaked documents reveals an industry designed to sell
secrecy. This is one story from a Four Corners investigation into the
ATO deputy commissioner Mark Konza said investigations had led to 19
companies that appear to be exploiting a scheme known as cross-currency
interest rate swaps.
“It’s a two-step scheme, it’s difficult to detect, and it took us a little
while to detect it, but now we have we are following it up, we’re making a
lot of inquiries about it,” he told Four Corners.
The swaps can be perfectly valid – they can swap, for example, a loan in
$US to a loan in $A, with each side effectively swapping the risks and
interest rate of the original currency for the risks and interest rate of
the swap currency.
Tax experts say when the swaps are done between a parent and its
subsidiary they can sometimes be used by multinationals to avoid tax.
A total of 19 companies have faced ATO action over the scheme, with 13 of
them still under review.
On top of the targeted companies, the ATO has issued legally-binding
formal notices to advisory firms, asking them whether they helped
implement the swaps or other tax-driven schemes.
Four Corners can reveal 21 formal notices have been issued to accountants
and other so-called “intermediary” firms in Australia, with further action
And Mr Konza said the ATO was stretching its net offshore, saying
international tax regulators wanted to disrupt the operations of offshore
law firms in tax havens.
He also said the ATO wanted the Paradise Papers data to begin “analysing
the Australian implications”.
Coal miner Glencore used the scheme
The Paradise Papers show Australia’s largest coal miner, Swiss-based
Glencore, used the swap financing scheme that has been the subject of
scrutiny by the ATO.
Four Corners has also established the use of the swaps by Glencore was the
subject of a voluntary review by the ATO.
Glencore, which is also the world’s biggest commodity trader, produces and
exports coal, copper, zinc, nickel, oil, grain and cotton from Australia.
Its chief executive, Ivan Glasenberg, and four other executives became
billionaires when the company listed on the London stock exchange in 2011.
But it reports very little taxable profit in Australia.
In 2014, Glencore made $23.7 billion in revenue (more than Australia’s
second largest listed company, Westpac) and made $296 million in profit.
This figure represents about $1.30 in profit for every $100 in revenue. It
paid tax of $55 million on its profit.
The leaked documents reveal Glencore used the swaps in a $3.7 billion
refinancing of its Australian operations in 2013, and in a major
Australian restructure in 2014 that left it with debts of $US11.6 billion.
The complicated swap financing structures used by Glencore were routed
through Glencore companies in Bermuda.
High debt a tax avoidance strategy: Tax activists
Tax activists attribute Glencore’s low taxable profits in part to
deliberately high levels of debt and the use of complicated financing
structures to export taxable profits to low or no-tax countries such as
Major multinational companies, their lawyers and accountants work hard to
ensure their activities comply with tax law that states any financial
manoeuvring should not have a dominant purpose of reducing tax.
But Jim Henry, a New York-based senior adviser to the activist group Tax
Justice Network, said it was no surprise to see mining companies loaded up
with debt to avoid tax.
“Well, it’s a typical pattern that you would say many companies that are
involved in the extractive industries have used to basically move income
from high-tax jurisdictions to low-tax jurisdictions,” he said.
“It’s just a tax avoidance scheme. It’s been done by dozens of companies.
The mineral industry is rife with this behaviour.
“I think Glencore is one of the more egregious participants in this, but
it’s not unusual.”
Use of swaps dropped by Glencore
Glencore said it voluntarily participated in a “pre-lodgement compliance
review” with the ATO and disclosed and discussed its use of the swaps.
It dropped the use of the swaps in 2016, but said this had nothing to do
with ATO action.
Glencore said it had used the swaps to hedge foreign exchange risks, but
they were no longer needed after a ruling from the ATO about how it
reported its financial accounts.
Glencore said it had recently shut many of its Bermuda-based companies, it
paid all taxes required by law, and debt had been cut in Australian
operations by $US4 billion since late 2014.
It said it was not currently under ATO audit or review about its use of
debt or the swaps.
However Glencore revealed it remained under ATO audit for its use of a
Swiss marketing hub and was objecting to assessments from two other
audits, which it has paid $US42 million to resolve.
The ATO now has about 20 major resources companies under audit as it steps
up investigations into the high use of debt by big mining and energy
companies, and their use of trading or marketing hubs.
Glencore said Australian income tax payments had been affected by
challenging market conditions, including a slump in commodity prices and
inherited tax losses, so “the business did not pay tax due to the lack of
profitability in the underlying operations”.
“Glencore’s operations in Australia are now profitable and hence tax will
be paid,” Glencore said.
Reporters: Stuart Washington, Marian Wilkinson