US Supreme Court "vacates" Rio Tinto Bougainville casePublished by MAC on 2013-05-07
Source: Post Courier, ABC Radio Australia
But lawyer vows to continue battle
The US Supreme Court has "vacated" (i.e. relinquished) an earlier decision by another court, to hear a case against Rio Tinto, brought by Bougainville islanders alleging its responsibility for war crimes and human rights abuses.
Steve Berman, a lawyer for the Bougainville plaintiffs admit this is a setback, and claims it represents a "complete reversal of well-established precedent spanning several decades". However, says Mr Berman, "the battle [is] not over" and his firm will now try to move the case back to the Ninth Circuit court.
Meanwhile, at its recent AGM in Papua New Guinea, Rio Tinto's Bougainville Copper subsidiary released a study which purported to lend weight to its own "case" for re-opening the Panguna mine.
Rio's case vacated
30 April 2013
THE United States Supreme Court last week vacated the landmark en banc decision by the Ninth Circuit in the long-standing Alien Tort Statute litigation Sarei v. Rio Tinto PLC (No. 11-649).
This is the case, originally filed in 2000, by Dr Alexis Sarei and other landowners of Panguna, alleging that mining giant Rio Tinto was responsible for war crimes, crimes against humanity and genocide in connection with its mining operations on Bougainville.
The case has been on-going in Seattle, United States of America.
This decision follows the Supreme Court's ruling last week in Kiobel v. Royal Dutch Petroleum (No. 10-1491) which affirmed the dismissal of claims brought by Nigerian nationals under the Alien Tort Statute for human rights violations allegedly committed by the government of Nigeria with the aid of Royal Dutch.
But lawyers representing the Bougainville landowners in this class action case told the Post-Courier yesterday that the battle was not over and that they would continue to advance the case on behalf of their clients as they have for more than a decade.
The lawyers, Brent Walton and Steve Berman, the Managing Partner of Hagens Berman Sobol Shapiro in a release to the Post-Courier from Seattle, United States of America said that the Court's decision was disappointing and a complete reversal of well-established precedent spanning several decades but advised they will not stop there.
"The Court's decision is disappointing and a complete reversal of well-established precedent spanning several decades," Steve Berman, the lead counsel for plaintiffs in the Rio Tinto litigation said.
"But the battle isn't over. We will continue to advance our case on behalf of our clients as we have for more than a decade."
The case will now move back to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, where it has already been argued four times. The Ninth Circuit will review the case in light of the Supreme Court's Kiobel decision and has asked parties to submit briefing by the end of next month.
"Like all civilized nations, the United States and its courts have long recognised the universal obligation to hold accountable those who commit the most deplorable human rights violations wherever they are committed," Mr Berman said. "This was true before the Supreme Court decision and remains true today."
The case, one of the oldest on the federal docket, claims that Rio Tinto's mining operations on Bougainville destroyed the local environment, dumping massive amounts of toxic waste that poisoned residents and dispossessed them of ancestral lands. Following a popular uprising by residents and workers at the mine, protesting the damage and slave-like working conditions, Rio allegedly orchestrated a military blockade and assault on the island. The blockade, according to court documents, resulted in the deaths of an estimated 15,000 native Bougainvillians, including several thousand children.
The lawyers are planning another visit to PNG and Bougainville in the not too distant future.
Rio Tinto says its Bougainville mine is viable
ABC Radio Australia - Pacific Beat
30 April 2013
The Rio-Tinto mine that sparked the civil war on Papua New Guinea's island of Bougainville is economically viable and could be re-opened in as little as 6 years.
Rio Tinto says its Bougainville mine is viable (Credit: ABC)
Bougainville Copper, the Rio subsidiary that owns the mine lease, has just completed an order of magnitude study which shows the project is viable.
It is more than a decade since the war ended but sensitivities remain.
Jemima Garrett reports.
Presenter: Jemima Garrett
Speaker: Bougainville Copper's Managing Director, Peter Taylor, Former President, James Tanis
Keywords:re-opening Panguna mine
Bougainville Copper's Managing Director, Peter Taylor, has not set foot on the island since the war but has been working towards the re-opening of the mine.
The order of magnitude study released at the company's Annual General Meeting in Port Moresby is a first look at mine viability.
Even with commodity prices down, Mr Taylor is optimistic.
GARRETT: The mine has the potential to produce 170,000 tonnes of copper a year and half a million ounces of gold - putting it in the top ten gold and copper mines globally.
Start-up costs are estimated at around 5 billion dollars.
TAYLOR: I've estimated that it is about a six year project but that is on the basis of us getting access so we are not starting the clock now. It really depends on getting to the mine site and having a look what is there and confirming some of the assumptions we have made in that order of magnitude study.
GARRETT: More than 10,000 people died as a result of the civil war.
Bougainville went from being PNG's most prosperous province to a no-go zone with barely a school or a hospital operating.
Since the signing of the Peace Agreement in 2001 Bougainvilleans have been focussing on putting their lives and their economy back together.
That has prompted a reassessment of the value of Rio Tinto's mine at Panguna.
President John Momis is in favour of re-opening the mine and is preparing the way for detailed Bougainville wide discussions.
Former President, James Tanis, spent the war years fighting alongside rebel leader, Francis Ona.
TANIS: I come from a guerrilla army that fought against the Panguna mine but I have come to notice that there is already mining on Bougainville. After the conflict people now know the value of the stone under the ground. It has made me realise that mining is an industry that will be an important part of the Bougainville economy.
GARRETT:There is still a small minority of people who are strongly against re-opening of the Bougainville copper mine. How will you avoid bloodshed if there is a re-opening of the mine?
TANIS: I do believe we should re-open it but we have to be careful on how we follow the process, meaning that we have a small minority group and it is important that we listen to them, try to understand where they are coming from and come up with a solution that accommodates everybody.
GARRETT: Talking counts for a lot on Bougainville.
Bougainville Copper, MD Peter Taylor, says the negotiations to re-open the mine will not be rushed.
TAYLOR: What I have said to the Bougainville government and the landowners is I want them to set the agenda. I want them to tell me what it is that they want. So they will bring their agenda to the negotiating table and obviously we may have to compromise. But the different approach is going to be ..it won't be driven as it was in the first place by an Administration from Australia. It will be from day One negotiations between the people on the ground, the landowners in the mine site, the government of Bougainville and the other population of Bougainville.
GARRETT: Overseeing the negotiations will be the Board of Bougainville Copper which includes former Prime Minister Sir Rabbie Namaliu and its latest recruit, the widely respected former PNG community services Minister Dame Carol Kidu.
KIDU: As I am the first woman to go on there maybe I can bring some new perspectives. In terms of the corporate social responsibility I am very keen to get into that work later when it is appropriate.I am also interested to pursue the agendas of gender and social inclusion to ensure that, try to maximise any benefits and minimise the damage.
GARRETT: Conflict over mine revenue and environmental impacts fuelled the war on Bougainville.
James Tanis hopes modern mangement will make the difference.
TANIS: Panguna was negotiated in the 1960s when there was little knowledge on environmental issues mining brings. Technology has improved. Maybe with better technology, better environment policies and legislation, maybe we have a future with mining on Bougainville.