Please note that this journalist got two things wrong, the amount of thePublished by MAC on 2005-10-04
Please note that this journalist got two things wrong, the amount of the
suit - it is open ended, and the fact that it is only for the 1996 spill -
it is for all damages areas and people. Catherine
Placer Dome faces $115M lawsuit - Philippines sues mining giant for cleanup
of 1996 spill
The Ottawa Citizen
Tuesday, October 04, 2005
Vancouver-based Placer Dome Inc. is being sued in the U.S. for more than
$115 million over its role in the troubled Marcopper mine in the
The suit was to be filed today on behalf of the province of Marinduque,
where a spill at Marcopper sparked a national disaster in 1996. A recent
U.S. study found that for decades, toxins have been seeping into local
rivers from the now-defunct mine, in which Placer Dome owned a 39.9-per-cent
share until 1997.
The province of Marinduque wants money for the cleanup of land, rivers, bays
and coastlines, as well as compensation for affected villagers and the
repair of Marcopper's leaky mine-waste facilities.
Marcopper has a troubled history: In 1993, a dam holding back tonnes of
toxic sludge burst, contaminating a river and killing two villagers. Three
years later, a drainage plug at the same tailings pond failed. This time,
the flood of mine waste smothered all life in a major waterway, causing a
"After reaping the wealth of the province for decades, Placer Dome left us
with nothing but lost lives, environmental destruction and the bill for the
cleanup of all the toxic waste," says Allan Nepomuceno, a representative of
Placer Dome declined to comment before the formal statement of complaint had
been filed. However, spokeswoman Gayle Stewart said, "We understand the
national government of the Philippines has taken over remediation of the
site, and given this, we find the actions of ... Marinduque surprising."
Ms. Stewart referred to a July article in the Manila Bulletin in which the
Philippine government announced it would start fixing several dams and other
mine-waste facilities at Marcopper, which closed after the 1996 disaster.
A 2004 study by the U.S. Geological Survey said the mine's waste facilities
were crumbling and another disaster is imminent if they are not fixed
immediately. The mine has left a number of other lingering environmental
problems, including a causeway of tailings that stretches seven kilometres
into the sea, and mounds of potentially toxic mine waste piled along
riverbanks, the study noted.
After the 1996 spill, Placer Dome voluntarily put up more than $70 million
U.S. to repair damage from the accident, which sent almost 300,000 cubic
metres of potentially toxic mine waste into the Boac River, a major
waterway. It also paid $1.5 million U.S. in compensation to affected
The company left behind a technical crew until 2001 as well as a cleanup
fund to help remediate the disaster. Subsequent studies by its technical
staff found the cleanup successful, noting no impact on groundwater or on
"To me, that doesn't sound like running away," Keith Ferguson,
vice-president of safety and sustainability at Placer Dome, told the Citizen
earlier this year.
Mr. Ferguson also pointed out that Placer Dome was a minority shareholder in
the venture, and came forward with compensation only out of a sense of moral
But Catherine Coumans of the Ottawa-based advocacy group MiningWatch Canada
says Placer Dome was a key technical adviser for the mine from Day 1,
pointing out that for 25 years, the firm was the only mining company
involved in funding the venture.
For the first 17 years of the project, the only other major player was
former Philippine president Ferdinand Marcos, who held 49 per cent of the
shares until he was deposed in 1986, she points out. His shares were taken
over by the Philippine government, and later privatized in 1994. Earlier
this year, Joost Pekelharing, chairman of Marcopper's board, told the
Citizen, "It is obvious that during the period Placer was involved in the
mine, they were in fact managing the operations."
But, Mr. Ferguson denies Placer Dome was running the mine. He has admitted
some managers were "former employees."
The lawsuit comes just as the Canadian government is drafting its response
to a report from the standing committee on foreign affairs and international
development, which urged the government to adopt "clear legal norms" to hold
Canadian mining companies accountable for the social and environmental
impact of their operations overseas.
The government must respond by Oct. 19.