USA: Thacker Pass lithium mine approval challenged in courtsPublished by MAC on 2021-03-01
Source: Nnbw.com, Gbrw.org
The permitting was fast tracked by the Trump Administration.
A coalition of conservation and public accountability groups and a Nevada rancher filed two lawsuits in the District of Nevada challenging the approval of the Thacker Pass lithium mining project.
“The reckless permitting of the Thacker Pass lithium mine sets a bad precedent for the Energy Transition.” said John Hadder, Director of Great Basin Resource Watch.
The owner is Reno-based Lithium Nevada Corporation, a wholly owned subsidiary of Vancouver-based Lithium Americas Corporation. Lithium Americas is focused on advancing Thacker Pass and the Cauchari-Olaroz project in Jujuy, Argentina.
2019-03-25 Amnesty launches major campaign on lithium
2016-12-19 Lithium: Mining mountains of water in northern Argentina
Lawsuit filed to block $1.3 billion Lithium Nevada mine project
February 22, 2021
A Nevada rancher is suing federal regulators over approval of the Thacker Pass lithium mining project plotted for rural Northern Nevada, alleging it violates environmental laws and undermines changes he has made in his own livestock grazing practices to help threatened fish and wildlife.
Edward Bartell and Bartell Ranch LLC allege the Bureau of Land Management relied “entirely upon flawed and error-laden findings” in environmental assessments prepared by the mine’s own contractor, according to the lawsuit filed earlier this month in U.S. District Court in Reno.
According to the Associated Press, Bartell’s suit alleges the project will lower the groundwater table, harm the federally protected Lahontan cutthroat trout and imperil greater sage grouse and “transform much of our private lands into barren desert.”
The $1.3 billion open pit mining project entails the manufacturing of high-purity lithium chemicals as a byproduct of mineral processing near Thacker Pass in northern Humboldt County near Orovada, roughly 50 miles north-northwest of Winnemucca.
The project is owned by Reno-based Lithium Nevada Corporation, a wholly owned subsidiary of Vancouver-based Lithium Americas Corporation.
The BLM gave final approval to the project in January, with Winnemucca BLM District Manager Ester McCullough saying, "The Thacker Pass Mine will provide a long-term solution for the growing need for lithium while providing economic benefits for Humboldt County, especially around Orovada, McDermitt and Winnemucca."
Not long after the Jan. 15 BLM approval, activists aiming to stop the project launched a permanent protest encampment at the site. Lawyer Will Falk, who is among the protestors on site, said they mean to stay for as long as it takes to protect the old-growth sagebrush mountainside.
Alexi Zawadzki, CEO of Lithium Nevada, defended the project in a statement to the AP last week.
“The environmental analysis confirmed the proposed mine would be constructed and operated in an environmentally responsible manner, and we are confident that the full environmental review and mitigation measures included in the (bureau’s decision) will address the concerns raised by this judicial review,” he said.
Bartell’s suit alleges the company’s consultants “relied upon grossly inaccurate, incomplete, and inadequate data for constructing baselines and models purporting to estimate impacts to water resources” caused by groundwater pumping associated with the mine, according to the AP.
“BLM has wholesale ignored the inconsistency of the mine with BLM’s sage grouse plans and associated regulations,” the lawsuit said, noting the project borders one of Nevada’s largest remaining populations of greater sage grouse.
Per past reports, full-scale construction on the mine was slated to begin this year, with the company projecting the third quarter of 2022 as an estimated target date to start production.
It’s projected to produce 1,000 jobs during construction and 300 full-time jobs once completed, generating $75 million in state and local tax revenue over a decade.
Conservation and Public Accountability Groups File Legal Challenge to the Thacker Pass Lithium Mine Joint Media
26 February 2021
“Renewable energy and electric cars aren’t green when they depend on mining that destroys important wildlife habitat and causes extinction,” said Kelly Fuller, Energy and Mining Campaign Director for Western Watersheds Project. “The Thacker Pass mine will devastate greater sage- grouse and other wildlife. We need to transition to renewables in an environmentally sustainable, rather than an environmentally problematic, way.”
Metals mining is the most polluting industry in the United States, and the local communities of Orovada and Kings River Valley are deeply concerned about how the mine will affect them.
“I am opposed to the Lithium mine being proposed for Thacker Pass,” said Wendelyn Muratore, Kings River Valley resident and member of Great Basin Resource Watch. “The impacts to our air quality, destruction of wildlife and habitat, dumping of hazardous chemicals, tightening of our water supply, increase in traffic at 75 semi trucks per day, and damage to our ranching and farming should make one stop and rethink this mine. Our communities along with our way of life and livelihoods should not be made to suffer in the name of ‘progress.’ ”
Thacker Pass is critically important to wildlife because it connects the Double H Mountains to the Montana Mountains. The pass also provides lower-elevation habitat that wildlife need to survive the winter. It contains thousands of acres of the most important type of greater sage-grouse habitat and two pronghorn migration corridors. Golden eagles nesting in the nearby cliffs and canyons forage there for food to feed their chicks. Local springs are the only place in the world where the Kings River pyrg, a rare type of springsnail, are known to live.
“The Bureau of Land Management must manage Thacker Pass and connecting mountains to preserve essential sage grouse habitat, old growth sagebrush, golden eagle nests, endemic springsnails and additional wildlife,” said Kevin Emmerich, Co-Founder of Basin and Range Watch. “The unique viewshed and dark skies should be managed to retain the existing character of the landscape. The open pit, waste rock facilities, noise and water use required for the Thacker Pass Lithium Mine all would cause critical damage to a remaining stronghold for local wildlife, and the viewshed will be damaged forever.”
“The Montana Mountains landscape has long been identified as a key area for biodiversity protection in Nevada,” said Katie Fite, Public Lands Director for Wildlands Defense. “Along with adjacent Oregon wild lands, it constitutes one of the last big blocks of the sagebrush sea free of development. Pygmy rabbits, migratory birds and other wildlife suffered a major blow from wildfire a decade ago and habitat has not yet recovered. Now this mega-mine will obliterate vital remaining sagebrush. The mine’s regional disturbance footprint will wallop struggling wildlife populations, causing new declines.”
Today’s legal complaint alleges that the Bureau of Land Management violated federal laws when it approved the Thacker Pass Lithium Mine’s Plans of Operation on January 15, 2021, including the National Environmental Policy Act and Federal Land Policy and Management Act.
“The reckless permitting of the Thacker Pass lithium mine sets a bad precedent for the Energy Transition.” said John Hadder, Director of Great Basin Resource Watch. “An example of getting the permit over good public process and addressing environmental and community concerns. Frontline communities like King River Valley and Orovada, Nevada that would shoulder effects of mining deserve an independent analysis of the mine and ask if all is being done to minimize the need for these raw materials.”
Plaintiffs further argue that BLM failed in its duty to protect public resources by allowing a mine that will be a source of groundwater pollution for at least 300 years and not requiring long-term financial assurances.
According to Lithium Nevada Corporation’s Plans of Operation, the mine would entail:
- excavation of a large open pit roughly 2.3 miles long by about half a mile at the widest
- removal of 17.2 million tons of rock and ore per year (phase 2)
- direct surface disturbance of 5,694 acres (total project size would be 17,933 acres)
- on-site sulfuric acid plant - 5,800 tons of acid per day during phase 2
- ultimately pumping up to 1.7 billion gallons of water per year
- estimated lifetime of 41 years and 5 years of reclamation
Kelly Fuller, Western Watersheds Project, 928-322-8449; firstname.lastname@example.org John Hadder, Great Basin Resource Watch, 775-348-1986; email@example.com Kevin Emmerich, Basin and Range Watch, 775-553-2806; firstname.lastname@example.org Katie Fite, Wildlands Defense, 208-871-5738; email@example.com