MAC: Mines and Communities

Australian judge rules against coal mine on climate change grounds

Published by MAC on 2019-02-13
Source: PlanetArk

In what might be a first, an Australian judge has sent down-under a coal mining company from its hilly perch.

Other such ventures aren't necessarily now put under the hammer, including Adani's huge Carmichael project - potentially a far larger contributor to adverse climate change.



Landmark ruling holds promise for addressing climate change

Liam Taylor


12 February 2019

A NSW judge has rejected a potential open-cut mine in the town of Gloucester, NSW due to the negative impact it would have on greenhouse gas emissions and climate change.

Chief Judge Brian Preston ruled the negative impacts of the mine outweighed its economic and other public benefits, primarily because it would increase greenhouse gas emissions at a time when they urgently need to be cut.

The mine was initially proposed and rejected by the NSW Independent Planning Commission in late 2017. In response, the company behind the proposed Rocky Hill mine, Gloucester Resources Limited, took the NSW Planning Minister to the Land and Environment Court to appeal the decision.

The company argued the development would provide economic development in the region, with the mine expected to create 170 jobs and produce 21 million tonnes of coal over 16 years. Judge Preston, however, ruled these benefits paled in comparison to the negative impact in terms of emissions, with the burning of this much coal expected to produce over two million tons of carbon dioxide.

“The global problem of climate change needs to be addressed by multiple local actions to mitigate emissions,” Judge Preston said in his judgement.

“… the emissions of the coal mine and its coal product will increase global total concentrations of [greenhouse gases] at a time when what is now urgently needed, in order to meet generally agreed climate targets, is a rapid and deep decrease in emissions.”

Many see the ruling as potentially influential in the approvals process for future fossil fuel projects, with Climate Council chief executive Amanda McKenzie stating the court effectively ruled that coal “is bad for us”.

“If I was proposing to build a coal mine right now, I’d be feeling pretty nervous,” McKenzie said.

Positive Action

If you are a business-owner looking to decarbonise and reduce your own carbon footprint, check out the range of clean energy solutions offered by Planet Ark Power.
To stay up to date with the latest in climate science, follow the Climate Council, Australia’s leading climate change communications organisation.


Subscribe to Positive Environment News
Positive Environment News has been compiled using publicly available information. Planet Ark does not take responsibility for the accuracy of the original information and encourages readers to check the references before using this information for their own purposes.
Liam Taylor
Author: Liam Taylor
Liam is Planet Ark's Communications Coordinator. Prior to joining Planet Ark Liam spent his time studying global environmental issues, travelling Southeast Asia on the cheap and working for a sustainable property management company in Bali, Indonesia.

Related News:

Aussie posties to go green with electric trikes »
Everyday Enviro with Elise - Plugged in with my favourite sustainability podcasts »
First power to flow from world's biggest offshore wind farm »
New Zealand supermarkets go nude and ditch plastic »
Drinking your fill with the U.K. Refill campaign »
Sydney wins bid to host global climate conference for women »


Home | About Us | Companies | Countries | Minerals | Contact Us
© Mines and Communities 2013. Web site by Zippy Info