USA: Rio Tinto Targets Environmental ActivistsPublished by MAC on 2013-11-02
Source: Wisconsin Resources Protection Council
Previous article on MAC: Rio Tinto hits a snag in US copper mine clean-up
Rio Tinto Targets Environmental Activists
Wisconsin Resources Protection Council statement
29 October 2013
Back in 2007 the Wisconsin Resources Protection Council (WRPC; Tomahawk, WI) embarked on a mission to hold Flambeau Mining Company (FMC) accountable for water pollution problems caused by the company's Flambeau Mine near Ladysmith, WI. FMC, at one time managed by Kennecott Minerals (Salt Lake City, UT) is a wholly owned subsidiary of Rio Tinto (London, UK).
This project was never just about us here in Wisconsin ... it was about trying to help clean water advocates in the entire Great Lakes region and beyond protect their own waters from adverse impacts linked to sulfide mining operations. As you know, the mining industry has held up the Flambeau Mine to YOU, the people of Minnesota, Michigan, Wisconsin, Alaska and who knows where else around the world as an example of "environmentally responsible mining" in efforts to convince you to "let them in" and mine in YOUR communities. Our lawsuit was meant to bring out the facts about the serious pollution problems at the Flambeau Mine site and thereby debunk the myth of the "environmentally responsible" Flambeau Mine and give you ammunition to use in your own battles.
We scored a partial victory in in July 2012, when the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Wisconsin ruled that FMC had indeed violated the Clean Water Act on numerous counts at the Flambeau Mine site.
Unfortunately, however, FMC appealed the decision, and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit proceeded to let the mining company "off the hook." The Court remained silent on whether or not FMC had violated the Clean Water Act. Instead, they ruled that we could not enforce the Clean Water Act against FMC (even though the company had indeed violated the Act, as determined by the U.S. District Court) because the mine permit issued by the State of Wisconsin "shielded" the company from prosecution.
In the process, no one was held accountable for the fact that the Flambeau Mine has polluted a tributary of the Flambeau River to the point where the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources (DNR) has recommended to the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) that the stream be listed as "impaired" for copper and zinc toxicity linked to the mining operation. And absolutely NOTHING has been done about the high levels of toxins (most notably manganese) in the groundwater at the mine site. You see, groundwater pollution at mine sites in Wisconsin has been legalized by the Wisconsin DNR (see NR 182.075, Wisconsin Administrative Code), so we could not argue that point in either state or federal court.
The latest twist is that FMC, owned by one of the wealthiest multinational mining corporations in the world (Rio Tinto), is "going after" WRPC, Laura Gauger and their fellow plaintiff (Center for Biological Diversity, Tucson, AZ) to recover various "costs" the company accrued in the lawsuit ... to the tune of $154,000.
Our lawyers are fighting the dollar amount demanded by FMC, but it appears we will be required to pay FMC/Rio Tinto many thousands of dollars.